Consensys sues SEC, seeks court declaration that Ethereum is not a security

Share This Post

Consensys filed a lawsuit against the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) on April 25 over allegations that the watchdog has overstepped in its authority in trying to regulate Ethereum (ETH).

The lawsuit alleges that the SEC aims to unlawfully regulate Ethereum through enforcement actions against various companies, including Consensys, constituting “aggressive and unlawful” overreach.

Consensys intends to prove that the SEC does not have legal authority to regulate ETH, user-controlled software interfaces, or the Ethereum blockchain more broadly.

Consensys wants the court to declare that Ethereum is not a security and that the firm neither acts as a broker nor sells securities by operating MetaMask. It also wants the court to declare that legal action or investigations based on those grounds would exceed the SEC’s authority.

Furthermore, Consensys is seeking an injunction that prevents a continued SEC investigation of, or future enforcement action against, its MetaMask wallet and related ETH sales. The SEC warned Consensys of potential legal action through a Wells notice and phone conference on April 10. Metamask’s staking and swap features are areas of concern.

Three-prong argument

The lawsuit has three prongs. Consensys first asserted that the SEC only has jurisdiction over securities and has previously agreed ETH is not a security.

Consensys secondly asserted that the SEC’s approach wrongly classifies non-financial platforms as financial applications. It argued that ETH supports applications on Ethereum and, therefore, has non-financial utility separate from its role as a commodity. The firm also said the SEC has no authority to regulate the internet’s technological development in such a way.

Finally, Consensys asserted that MetaMask and other applications are not securities brokers but rather allow users to buy, sell, and transfer ETH through broader access.

The case, filed in the US District Court for the Northern District of Texas, names the SEC and its chair, Gary Gensler, as defendants.

Broader implications

Whether the SEC considers Ethereum a security is a long-standing issue, and the matter is relevant to the compliance efforts of any company or project that handles ETH.

Fortune reported on March 20 that the SEC had subpoenaed numerous crypto companies that have engaged with the Ethereum Foundation. The Ethereum Foundation itself seemingly received a subpoena from an unknown state authority at the time of the report.

One company in the Ethereum ecosystem, Uniswap, received a Wells notice on April 10, warning of potential charges. However, it is unclear if the SEC’s potential charges against Uniswap are directly related to ETH.

Whether the SEC treats ETH as a security could also impact the approval of spot Ethereum ETFs. SEC chair Gary Gensler identified Bitcoin as a non-security commodity upon the approval of spot Bitcoin ETFs in January and emphasized that the current decision only applied to the asset.

The post Consensys sues SEC, seeks court declaration that Ethereum is not a security appeared first on CryptoSlate.

Read Entire Article
spot_img
- Advertisement -spot_img

Related Posts

Virtuals Launches AI Agent on Ronin Blockchain With JAIHOZ Token

Ronin, a blockchain designed for Web3 gaming, has partnered with Virtuals Protocol to incorporate an artificial intelligence (AI) agent into its platform Blockchain Collaboration Brings JAIHOZ Token

Dogecoin Whales Go on 470 Million DOGE Buying Spree Amid Bullish Recovery In Major Metrics

Surprisingly, Dogecoin whales are on a massive buying spree, as new reports show that these large-scale investors have added a whopping 470 million DOGE into their portfolios This substantial

Kenya Moves To Legalize Crypto – Details

The Republic of Kenya is currently making moves to create a legal framework for crypto operations Interestingly, this rather exciting development comes shortly after the International Monetary Fund

‘Dino Coins’ Roar Back: XRP, XLM, and ADA Lead the Charge in Weekend Gains

Coins colloquially labeled as “dino coins” have dominated the weekend’s crypto gains, with XRP, XLM, and ADA enjoying substantial upticks over the past 24 hours Leading this

Ethereum Sees $1.4 Billion In Exchange Outflows This Week – Strong Accumulation Trend?

Ethereum has faced a challenging start to the year, shedding 15% from its recent local highs and dipping to a low of $3,157 The altcoin leader’s decline comes amid heightened market volatility and

Crypto ATM Numbers Approach Record High: A Steady Recovery After Industry Shocks

After a turbulent 2023 followed by a recovery in 2024, the global count of crypto-automated teller machines (ATMs) is inching closer to its former high of 39,958, achieved on Dec 1, 2022 Crypto ATMs