Menu

Categories:

Hot right now:

Follow on:

Coinsurges provides coverage of fintech, blockchain, and Bitcoin, delivering the most recent news and analyses on the future of money. Stay up-to-date with live prices, charts, and trading options for the top exchanges. Keep track of the day's top cryptocurrency gainers and losers, as well as which coins have experienced gains and losses in the past 24 hours.
Trust Coinsurges as your go-to source for all news and updates in the industry.

Menu

Categories:

Hot right now:

Follow on:

Coinsurges provides coverage of fintech, blockchain, and Bitcoin, delivering the most recent news and analyses on the future of money. Stay up-to-date with live prices, charts, and trading options for the top exchanges. Keep track of the day's top cryptocurrency gainers and losers, as well as which coins have experienced gains and losses in the past 24 hours.
Trust Coinsurges as your go-to source for all news and updates in the industry.

Crypto Clash: Kraken Challenges SEC’s Definition Of Securities

Share This Post

Crypto exchange Kraken has intensified its fight against the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) by formally submitting a reply in support of its motion to dismiss the agency’s lawsuit. The filing, dated May 9, 2024, challenges the SEC’s claim that Kraken operated as an unregistered exchange dealing with securities, specifically “investment contracts.”

Led by Matthew C. Solomon from Cleary Gottlieb Steen & Hamilton LLP, Kraken’s legal team disputes the SEC’s allegations, asserting that no specific investment contracts traded, brokered, or settled on Kraken’s platform have been identified. They argue that crypto assets alone, which are the only products alleged to have been handled by Kraken, do not meet the definition of investment contracts under federal securities laws.

Kraken Fights For The Entire Crypto Industry

The filing emphasizes a critical flaw in the SEC’s approach, accusing the regulatory body of conflating primary offerings conducted outside of Kraken with secondary crypto market transactions on the platform. Kraken’s attorneys contend that the SEC’s approach ignores the distinct legal treatment required for primary and secondary market transactions under the Securities Act of 1933 and the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.

Kraken’s submission states, “The transactions alleged to have occurred on Kraken are blind bid/ask secondary market sales of digital assets… unaccompanied by any contractual terms or other obligations that may have existed at the initial offering.” This, they argue, could improperly extend the SEC’s regulatory reach to virtually any digital asset or commodity by asserting an associated “investment concept” or “ecosystem.”

Further challenging the SEC’s jurisdiction, Kraken’s lawyers invoke the major questions doctrine, arguing that the expansive interpretation of regulatory authority over crypto assets should be explicitly authorized by Congress, not determined through litigation. They maintain that the Howey Test’s criteria — a standard used to define what constitutes an investment contract — are not met, as there was no investment of money in a common enterprise with a reasonable expectation of profits predominantly from the efforts of others.

The SEC initially sued Kraken in November, after previously settling charges over Kraken’s staking services. In its opposition filed last month, the SEC defended its actions, stating, “it is simply not the case that this enforcement action exceeds the authority Congress granted the SEC.” The SEC argued that its enforcement aligns with the Howey test and its Congressional mandate, dismissing claims of overreach.

Related Reading: Taiwan Sets Sights On Crypto Firms With Tough New Jail Time Laws

The court is scheduled to hear arguments on the motion on June 12, 2024. If Kraken’s motion to dismiss is granted by Judge William H. Orrick, it could set a significant legal precedent for the entire crypto industry, potentially limiting the SEC’s ability to regulate secondary market transactions of crypto assets under the current legislative framework.

At press time, Bitcoin traded at $63,237.

Bitcoin price

Read Entire Article
spot_img
- Advertisement -spot_img

Related Posts

U.S. SEC Delays Decision on Canary Litecoin ETF: LTC Price Drops Over 3%

The post US SEC Delays Decision on Canary Litecoin ETF: LTC Price Drops Over 3% appeared first on Coinpedia Fintech News The US SEC is now seeking public comment on whether the proposal to list the

Defense Seeks Dismissal in Samourai Wallet Case After FinCEN Disclosure, DOJ Policy Shift

The legal team for Samourai Wallet co-founders Keonne Rodriguez and William Hill has requested dismissal of criminal charges, citing newly disclosed FinCEN guidance that contradicted prosecutors’

Democratic opposition threatens GENIUS Act, jeopardizing 2025 crypto agenda – Galaxy

The Senate GENIUS Act bill, designed to establish federal rules for stablecoins, is facing resistance from key Democrats, jeopardizing the prospects for broader crypto legislation in 2025  The

Ethereum Breaks Massive Downtrend Price Structure – Momentum Shift?

After enduring months of aggressive selling pressure, Ethereum is finally showing signs of life As bullish momentum slowly builds, hopes for a recovery rally are beginning to resurface While ETH

Weekly ETF Recap: 3rd Straight Week of Gains as Bitcoin ETFs Attract $1.81 Billion

Bitcoin ETFs posted a $181 billion net inflow for the week ending May 2, marking their 3rd consecutive week in the green Ether ETFs also saw another week of gains, pulling in $10675 million and

Bitcoin’s Price Faces Risk Of A Pullback Once This Key Support Level Fails

During the ongoing market uptrend, Bitcoin continues to lead the bullish wave as the leading crypto asset records significant gains, pushing it to price levels above $95,000 While BTC’s price may