SEC Wins Case Against Crypto Influencer Ian Balina For Securities Laws Violation

Share This Post

On Wednesday, a Texas federal court judge ruled in favor of the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in the case against crypto influencer Ian Balina. The case is part of the Sparkster saga that started in 2018.

The Case Against The Crypto Influencer

In 2022, influencer and Token Metrics CEO Ian Balina was accused of violating securities laws. The SEC charged Balina for his involvement in the Initial Coin Offering (ICO) of an unregistered security.

According to the court documents, Software development company Sparkster Ltd conducted an unregistered securities offering with the Sparkster (SPRK) token between April and July 2018. The ICO raised around $30 million from 4,000 US-based and international investors.

The Commission argues that Balina violated Sections 5(a) and 5(c) of the Securities Act after selling and offering to sell unregistered securities through his Sparkster pool. Moreover, they alleged that the crypto influencer failed to disclose the “considerations received” from buying and promoting the token, violating Section 7.

In the lawsuit, the SEC claimed that Balina had agreed to receive a 30% bonus from Sparkster for purchasing 43,333,333 SPRK tokens at $0.15. This bonus was part of a deal between the crypto influencer and the company’s CEO, Sajjad Daya.

Daya and Balina allegedly negotiated a contract in May 2018, in which YouTubers would buy and promote the SPRK tokens on their platforms. In the following months, Balina endorsed his “Sparkster Private Sale Whitelist” to his Patreon and Telegram members.

However, the influencer failed to address his contract with the company while promoting the token. Instead, he stated it was “not a paid endorsement” and that he “was not paid off by Sparkster” on different occasions.

Judge Grants Victory To The SEC

Balina contended the SEC’s claims in November 2022.  He argued “he was fooled by Sparkster,” adding that he lost money after purchasing the crypto tokens, like the other pool members.

He also denied receiving compensation for recommending the SPRK tokens. The influencer alleged receiving “a volume discount during a private pre-sale purchase,” the same “other purchasers typically received in the industry.”

Moreover, the defendant claimed that the Court should “grant Summary Judgment in his favor” since the SPRK tokens were not securities. Similarly, the court documents revealed that the YouTuber considered that “liability did not attach in the United States” as he was outside the country during the promotional period.

On May 22, Judge David Alan Ezra ruled in favor of the SEC. The Court granted the Commission partial victory and denied Balina’s Motion for Summary Judgment.

Crypto

As seen in the document, the Court considered that the influencer’s ties to the US were sufficient to show he “purposefully targeted” American investors. This decision was based on the use of US social media platforms and the larger share of US-based investors in the Sparkster pool.

Judge Ezra also considered that Balina had violated Securities laws as there was “sufficient evidence to show that Sparkster sought money from investors,” and STRK tokens meet the criteria of the Howey test.

Ultimately, the SEC failed to prove that the influencer violated Section 7. The court stated that there were factual inconsistencies in whether there was a prior agreement for compensation in exchange for promotion. As a result, the court declined to decide this issue on summary judgment.

Crypto, TOTAL

Read Entire Article
spot_img
- Advertisement -spot_img

Related Posts

Bitcoin Price Watch: Struggles at $84K—Will Bulls Take Control?

Bitcoin traded at $84,222 on March 15, 2025, with a market capitalization of $167 trillion, a 24-hour global trade volume of $2599 billion, and an intraday price range between $82,705 and $85,139,

Major leadership shift at HK Asia Holdings as Bitcoin Magazine takes the helm

In a significant move that solidifies Bitcoin Magazine’s presence in Asia, HK Asia Holdings (01723HK) has announced key leadership changes effective March 14, 2025 This development marks a

Top Altcoins to Invest in as Pump.fun Mania Fizzles Out

The meme coin frenzy that took the crypto world by storm is now showing signs of exhaustion  Platforms like Pumpfun, which allowed anyone to launch altcoins in minutes, are experiencing a sharp

Bitcoin Breaches 12-Year Support Line Against Gold – Is The Bull Run Over?

As Bitcoin (BTC) struggles amid the latest crypto market pullback – failing to decisively break past the $84,000 resistance – gold (XAU) continues its impressive rally, soaring to a

Pakistan forms new ‘Crypto Council’ to regulate blockchain and digital assets

The government of Pakistan has established the Pakistan Crypto Council (PCC) to oversee the integration and use of blockchain technology and digital assets into the nation’s financial landscape

Stablecoins Thrive as Crypto Stumbles: A $4.23B Growth Spree in 2 Weeks

While the crypto market contracted over the past two weeks, the stablecoin sector has ballooned by $423 billion since March 1, defying the broader trend Digital Dollars Dominate With Over 8% of